Every head coach on this site has a main influence: the coach whose staffs they spent the most, and the most important, seasons on. Sooner or later a lot of them end up on the other sideline from that coach. Since 1920, 108 head coaches have faced the coach who shaped them most, 296 times in all.
The teacher usually wins. In January, it isn’t close.
169–124
teachers’ record against their students
21–8
teachers’ record in the playoffs
56%
of first meetings won by the teacher
Teachers win 57% of these games. That’s a big edge in a league built so any team can beat any other, and it grows when the stakes do: students have won 8 of 29 playoff meetings.
The most-played matchup
John Harbaugh learned the most under Andy Reid, then faced that coach 10 times as a head coach. Every game
The most one-sided
Among pairs who have met at least four times, these students have had the hardest time with the coach who taught them.
| Student | Teacher | Years | Student’s record |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1999–2000 | 0–4 | ||
| Dan Henning | 1983–1989 | 0–4 | |
| 2017–2023 | 0–4 | ||
| 2016–2017 | 0–4 | ||
| 1969–1978 | 1–5–1 | ||
| 1990–1992 | 1–5 | ||
| 2013–2015 | 1–5 | ||
| 2008–2025 | 2–8 |
The students who flipped it
A few students got the better of the coach who taught them.
Waiting for the first win
Mike McCoy lost the first 5 meetings with John Fox before winning one. 6 students met the teacher at least three times and never won: Chris Palmer (0–4 against Tom Coughlin), Dan Henning (0–4 against Joe Gibbs), Doug Pederson (0–4 against Andy Reid), Hue Jackson (0–4 against Marvin Lewis), Clive Rush (0–3 against Weeb Ewbank), Sam Wyche (0–3 against Bill Walsh).
Every playoff meeting
-
2024 NFC Wild Card PlayoffKevin O'Connell vs. teacher Sean McVay Teacher won, Minnesota Vikings 9, Los Angeles Rams 27
-
2023 AFC ChampionshipJohn Harbaugh vs. teacher Andy Reid Teacher won, Kansas City Chiefs 17, Baltimore Ravens 10
-
2023 NFC Divisional PlayoffMatt LaFleur vs. teacher Kyle Shanahan Teacher won, Green Bay Packers 21, San Francisco 49ers 24
-
2022 AFC Divisional PlayoffDoug Pederson vs. teacher Andy Reid Teacher won, Jacksonville Jaguars 20, Kansas City Chiefs 27
-
2021 NFC Divisional PlayoffMatt LaFleur vs. teacher Kyle Shanahan Teacher won, San Francisco 49ers 13, Green Bay Packers 10
-
2019 NFC ChampionshipMatt LaFleur vs. teacher Kyle Shanahan Teacher won, Green Bay Packers 20, San Francisco 49ers 37
-
2016 NFC Divisional PlayoffDan Quinn vs. teacher Pete Carroll Student won, Seattle Seahawks 20, Atlanta Falcons 36
-
2016 NFC Wild Card PlayoffBen McAdoo vs. teacher Mike McCarthy Teacher won, New York Giants 13, Green Bay Packers 38
-
2013 AFC Divisional PlayoffMike McCoy vs. teacher John Fox Teacher won, San Diego Chargers 17, Denver Broncos 24
-
2008 NFC Wild Card PlayoffBrad Childress vs. teacher Andy Reid Teacher won, Philadelphia Eagles 26, Minnesota Vikings 14
-
2006 Super Bowl XLILovie Smith vs. teacher Tony Dungy Teacher won, Indianapolis Colts 29, Chicago Bears 17
-
2006 AFC Wild Card PlayoffEric Mangini vs. teacher Bill Belichick Teacher won, New York Jets 16, New England Patriots 37
-
2006 AFC Wild Card PlayoffHerman Edwards vs. teacher Tony Dungy Teacher won, Kansas City Chiefs 8, Indianapolis Colts 23
-
2005 AFC Wild Card PlayoffMarvin Lewis vs. teacher Bill Cowher Teacher won, Pittsburgh Steelers 31, Cincinnati Bengals 17
-
2003 NFC Wild Card PlayoffMike Sherman vs. teacher Mike Holmgren Student won, Seattle Seahawks 27, Green Bay Packers 33 (OT)
-
2002 Super Bowl XXXVIIBill Callahan vs. teacher Jon Gruden Teacher won, Oakland Raiders 21, Tampa Bay Buccaneers 48
-
2002 AFC Wild Card PlayoffHerman Edwards vs. teacher Tony Dungy Student won, Indianapolis Colts 0, New York Jets 41
-
1998 Super Bowl XXXIIIMike Shanahan vs. teacher Dan Reeves Student won, Denver Broncos 34, Atlanta Falcons 19
-
1998 NFC Wild Card PlayoffSteve Mariucci vs. teacher Mike Holmgren Student won, Green Bay Packers 27, San Francisco 49ers 30
-
1997 NFC ChampionshipSteve Mariucci vs. teacher Mike Holmgren Teacher won, Green Bay Packers 23, San Francisco 49ers 10
-
1996 NFC Divisional PlayoffMike Holmgren vs. teacher George Seifert Student won, San Francisco 49ers 14, Green Bay Packers 35
-
1996 NFC Wild Card PlayoffRay Rhodes vs. teacher George Seifert Teacher won, Philadelphia Eagles 0, San Francisco 49ers 14
-
1995 NFC Divisional PlayoffMike Holmgren vs. teacher George Seifert Student won, Green Bay Packers 27, San Francisco 49ers 17
-
1994 AFC Wild Card PlayoffBill Belichick vs. teacher Bill Parcells Student won, New England Patriots 13, Cleveland Browns 20
-
1993 AFC Wild Card PlayoffBill Cowher vs. teacher Marty Schottenheimer Teacher won, Pittsburgh Steelers 24, Kansas City Chiefs 27 (OT)
-
1988 Super Bowl XXIIISam Wyche vs. teacher Bill Walsh Teacher won, Cincinnati Bengals 16, San Francisco 49ers 20
-
1972 NFC Divisional PlayoffDick Nolan vs. teacher Tom Landry Teacher won, Dallas Cowboys 30, San Francisco 49ers 28
-
1971 NFC ChampionshipDick Nolan vs. teacher Tom Landry Teacher won, San Francisco 49ers 3, Dallas Cowboys 14
-
1970 NFC ChampionshipDick Nolan vs. teacher Tom Landry Teacher won, Dallas Cowboys 17, San Francisco 49ers 10
Decade by decade
The students’ share of wins has never topped half in any decade with real numbers behind it:
Every pairing
A coach’s main influence is explained in how we build trees. Regular season and playoff games since 1920; these numbers update as games are played.