Story · November 21, 2026

The teacher usually wins

Every time an NFL head coach has faced the coach who shaped them most. The teachers lead, and in the playoffs it isn’t close.

21–8

teachers’ playoff record against their students

Every head coach on this site has a main influence: the coach whose staffs they spent the most, and the most important, seasons on. Sooner or later a lot of them end up on the other sideline from that coach. Since 1920, 108 head coaches have faced the coach who shaped them most, 296 times in all.

The teacher usually wins. In January, it isn’t close.

169–124

teachers’ record against their students

21–8

teachers’ record in the playoffs

56%

of first meetings won by the teacher

Teachers win 57% of these games. That’s a big edge in a league built so any team can beat any other, and it grows when the stakes do: students have won 8 of 29 playoff meetings.

The most-played matchup

John Harbaugh John Harbaugh student

2–8

2008–2025

Andy Reid Andy Reid teacher

John Harbaugh learned the most under Andy Reid, then faced that coach 10 times as a head coach. Every game

The most one-sided

Among pairs who have met at least four times, these students have had the hardest time with the coach who taught them.

StudentTeacherYearsStudent’s record
Chris PalmerChris Palmer Tom CoughlinTom Coughlin 1999–2000 0–4
Dan Henning Joe GibbsJoe Gibbs 1983–1989 0–4
Doug PedersonDoug Pederson Andy ReidAndy Reid 2017–2023 0–4
Hue JacksonHue Jackson Marvin LewisMarvin Lewis 2016–2017 0–4
Dick NolanDick Nolan Tom LandryTom Landry 1969–1978 1–5–1
Joe BugelJoe Bugel Joe GibbsJoe Gibbs 1990–1992 1–5
Mike McCoyMike McCoy John FoxJohn Fox 2013–2015 1–5
John HarbaughJohn Harbaugh Andy ReidAndy Reid 2008–2025 2–8

The students who flipped it

A few students got the better of the coach who taught them.

Waiting for the first win

Mike McCoy lost the first 5 meetings with John Fox before winning one. 6 students met the teacher at least three times and never won: Chris Palmer (0–4 against Tom Coughlin), Dan Henning (0–4 against Joe Gibbs), Doug Pederson (0–4 against Andy Reid), Hue Jackson (0–4 against Marvin Lewis), Clive Rush (0–3 against Weeb Ewbank), Sam Wyche (0–3 against Bill Walsh).

Every playoff meeting

Decade by decade

The students’ share of wins has never topped half in any decade with real numbers behind it:

1920s 50% (2 games)
1950s 25% (4 games)
1960s 44% (18 games)
1970s 35% (26 games)
1980s 39% (33 games)
1990s 49% (53 games)
2000s 47% (68 games)
2010s 31% (49 games)
2020s 44% (43 games)

Every pairing

StudentTeacherGamesStudent’s record
John Harbaugh Andy Reid 10 2–8
Ted Marchibroda Marv Levy 10 3–7
Marvin Lewis Bill Cowher 9 3–6
Bill Cowher Marty Schottenheimer 8 5–3
Eric Mangini Bill Belichick 8 3–5
Neill Armstrong Bud Grant 8 2–6
Dick Nolan Tom Landry 7 1–5–1
Matt LaFleur Kyle Shanahan 7 3–4
Ron Rivera Lovie Smith 7 5–2
Art Shell Tom Flores 6 5–1
Brian Flores Bill Belichick 6 4–2
Dan Quinn Pete Carroll 6 4–2
Gene Stallings Tom Landry 6 2–4
Joe Bugel Joe Gibbs 6 1–5
Mike McCoy John Fox 6 1–5
Mike Shanahan Dan Reeves 6 5–1
Steve Mariucci Mike Holmgren 6 3–3
Andy Reid Mike Holmgren 5 3–2
Bill Belichick Bill Parcells 5 3–2
Don McCafferty Weeb Ewbank 5 4–1
Chris Palmer Tom Coughlin 4 0–4
Dan Henning Joe Gibbs 4 0–4
Doug Pederson Andy Reid 4 0–4
Herman Edwards Tony Dungy 4 1–3
Hue Jackson Marvin Lewis 4 0–4
Jack Faulkner Sid Gillman 4 3–1
Mike Ditka Tom Landry 4 3–1
Mike Holmgren George Seifert 4 3–1
Nick Saban Bill Belichick 4 2–2
Bud Carson Chuck Noll 3 2–1
Clive Rush Weeb Ewbank 3 0–3
Dom Capers Bill Cowher 3 2–1
George Allen George Halas 3 2–1
Jack Del Rio John Fox 3 1–2
Josh McDaniels Bill Belichick 3 3–0
Leeman Bennett Chuck Knox 3 2–1
Lovie Smith Tony Dungy 3 1–2
Mike Sherman Mike Holmgren 3 3–0
Sam Wyche Bill Walsh 3 0–3
Sean McDermott Ron Rivera 3 2–1
Ben Johnson Dan Campbell 2 0–2
Ben McAdoo Mike McCarthy 2 0–2
Blanton Collier Paul Brown 2 1–1
Brad Childress Andy Reid 2 0–2
Dick Jauron Tom Coughlin 2 1–1
Doug Marrone Sean Payton 2 0–2
Gary Kubiak Mike Shanahan 2 2–0
George Wilson Buddy Parker 2 1–0–1
Hamp Pool Joe Stydahar 2 1–0–1
Jim Mora, Jr. Steve Mariucci 2 1–1
Joe Gibbs Don Coryell 2 2–0
Ken Meyer Chuck Knox 2 0–2
Kevin O'Connell Sean McVay 2 0–2
Mike LaFleur Sean McVay 2 1–1
Mike McDaniel Kyle Shanahan 2 1–1
Mike Nixon Joe Kuharich 2 1–1
Nick Skorich Blanton Collier 2 0–2
Paddy Driscoll George Halas 2 1–1
Ray Rhodes George Seifert 2 0–2
Rod Rust Marv Levy 2 0–2
Tom Fears Vince Lombardi 2 0–2
Vince Tobin Mike Ditka 2 1–1
Aaron Glenn Dan Campbell 1 0–1
Bill Austin Vince Lombardi 1 1–0
Bill Callahan Jon Gruden 1 0–1
Bobby Petrino Tom Coughlin 1 0–1
Brian Billick Dennis Green 1 1–0
Brian Callahan Zac Taylor 1 0–1
Brian Daboll Sean McDermott 1 0–1
Bruce Arians Mike Tomlin 1 0–1
Bruce Coslet Sam Wyche 1 0–1
Chan Gailey Dan Reeves 1 1–0
Dan Campbell Sean Payton 1 1–0
Dan Reeves Tom Landry 1 1–0
Dave Wannstedt Jimmy Johnson 1 1–0
DeMeco Ryans Kyle Shanahan 1 1–0
Dennis Allen Sean Payton 1 0–1
Dirk Koetter Jack Del Rio 1 0–1
Ed Biles Bum Phillips 1 0–1
Gregg Williams Jeff Fisher 1 0–1
Gus Bradley Pete Carroll 1 0–1
Jack Patera Neill Armstrong 1 1–0
Jeff Fisher Buddy Ryan 1 0–1
Jim Haslett Bill Cowher 1 1–0
Jim Schwartz Jeff Fisher 1 1–0
Jim Zorn Mike Holmgren 1 1–0
Joe Philbin Mike McCarthy 1 0–1
John Fox Jim Fassel 1 1–0
Jon Gruden Ray Rhodes 1 0–1
Kay Stephenson Chuck Knox 1 0–1
Kellen Moore Mike McCarthy 1 0–1
Kevin Stefanski Mike Zimmer 1 1–0
Liam Coen Sean McVay 1 0–1
Marty Mornhinweg Steve Mariucci 1 0–1
Matt Eberflus Frank Reich 1 1–0
Matt Nagy Andy Reid 1 0–1
Matt Patricia Bill Belichick 1 1–0
Mike Mularkey Bill Cowher 1 0–1
Mike Zimmer Marvin Lewis 1 1–0
Norv Turner Jimmy Johnson 1 1–0
Pat Shurmur Andy Reid 1 0–1
Paul Wiggin Dick Nolan 1 0–1
Ray Malavasi Chuck Knox 1 0–1
Robert Saleh Kyle Shanahan 1 0–1
Sean McVay Jay Gruden 1 0–1
Todd Bowles Bruce Arians 1 0–1
Todd Haley Ken Whisenhunt 1 1–0
Vince Lombardi Jim Lee Howell 1 0–1

A coach’s main influence is explained in how we build trees. Regular season and playoff games since 1920; these numbers update as games are played.